Creating the best NYC home gym has become a growing trend in 2024, as urban dwellers look to maximize limited space while enjoying the benefits of working out at home. This article will help you navigate the best Reddit recommendations for setting up an efficient home gym in a compact New York City apartment using top-rated products from Amazon. Whether you’re focused on strength training, cardio, or flexibility, we’ve curated a list of the top 10 gym essentials to fulfill your fitness needs.
1. Adjustable Dumbbells
One versatile piece of equipment that is essential for any home gym is a set of adjustable dumbbells. These allow you to adjust the weight according to your workout needs without taking up much space. The Bowflex SelectTech 552 Dumbbells are a popular choice among Reddit users in NYC. They have a unique dial system that allows you to switch weights easily from 5 to 52.5 pounds, making them suitable for both beginners and advanced lifters.
These dumbbells also come with a two-year warranty and help save you the hassle of having multiple dumbbell sets cluttering your small apartment. Users often rave about their durability and solid feel, making them a top contender for the best Reddit best NYC home gym setup.
No products found.
2. Resistance Bands
Resistance bands are a fantastic option for those with limited space but looking for an effective workout. The Fit Simplify Resistance Loop Exercise Bands are highly recommended on Reddit not just for their compact nature but also for their versatility. You can use them for strength training, flexibility, and rehabilitation exercises.
The bands come in different resistance levels, allowing for progressive workouts. Plus, they are easy to store, making them ideal for the best Reddit best NYC home gym setup. Users appreciate that they are lightweight, portable, and can easily fit into their workout routine.
- High End Exercise Bands. Our 12"³ By 2"³ Heavy Duty Loop Resistance Bands Come In 5 Varying Resistance Levels. This Makes Them Perfect Whether You Are Just Starting To Workout Or A Seasoned Workout Warrior. Our Extra Light And Light Bands Are Great For Beginners, While Our Medium, Heavy And Extra Heavy Exercise Bands Are Targeted For More Intermediate And Advanced Strength Training.
- Great With Any Workout. This Resistance Band Set Can Be Integrated Seamlessly With Various Popular Workout Program. Or Use Them For General Exercise, Stretching, Strength Training, Power Weight Programs. The Included Carry Bag Makes It Easy To Take Your Bands With You And Do Any Workout Away From Home Or Your Home Gym.
- Multiple Uses. While These Resistance Bands Are Often Used For Sports And Fitness, Physical Therapists Love These Physical Therapy Bands (Rehab Bands) To Help Them Rehabilitate Their Patients. Our Stretch Bands Work For People Suffering From Leg, Knee And Back Injuries. They Are Also Perfect For Use By Women After Pregnancy And Birth To Keep Their Bodies In Shape.
- Superior Quality. All Of Our Exercise Resistance Bands Are Thoroughly Tested Before We Ship Them Out To You. This Ensures Your Bands Are Easy On Skin And Will Provide You With A Worry Free Experience. The Instruction Booklet Includes Dozens Of Different Illustrated Exercises That Demonstrate How To Use Our Resistance Bands For Legs, Arms, Back, Shoulders, Ankles, Hips And Stomach.
- What You Get: Five Exercise Bands With Color-Coded Resistance Levels, Portable Travel Carry Bag And Instruction Guide.
3. Yoga Mat
A quality yoga mat is crucial for your home gym, especially if you plan on incorporating yoga or stretching into your routine. The Liforme Yoga Mat is a favorite among fitness enthusiasts practicing in small spaces. Its anti-slip surface and eco-friendly materials provide excellent comfort while being stable during intense workouts.
Many Reddit users highlight its durability, which stands the test of time, even with daily use. Additionally, its lightweight design makes it easy to roll up and store away after use. The combination of cushioning and grip also makes it suitable for various workouts beyond yoga, contributing to the best Reddit best NYC home gym vibe.
- ✅TRANSFORM YOUR PRACTICE – This Premium Yoga mat is designed to be the most innovative & comfortable mat on the market to optimise your home exercises. BALANCE - The mat is longer, wider and thicker than many other mats - 72.8" long x 26.8" wide and 0.16" thick, giving Yogis the space they crave, with perfect balance between firm stability and comfortable cushioning whilst staying lightweight.
- 🤸♂️ULTIMATE GRIP – This premium mat benefits from the ground-breaking Liforme “GripForMe” material that gives you unparalleled warrior-like grip whilst practicing.
- 🙏REVOLUTIONARY ALIGNMENT SYSTEM – Our intelligently designed unique “AlignForMe” system helps guide and prevent injuries to Yogis of all experience levels, maximising Yoga enjoyment.
- 🌍TRULY PLANET FRIENDLY – Liforme incorporates the most ‘body kind’ specially engineered eco-polyurethane and rubber. These mats are PVC free and made using high quality non-toxic materials that keep the mat clean and hygienic.
- 😀MADE BY YOGIS, FOR YOGIS – Liforme Yoga Mats are loved and adored by 100s of 1000s of Women and Men worldwide. Join the Liforme family with this unique, comfortable and thick Mat. ✅FREE BAG INCLUDED - Carry and protect your mat with the exclusive Liforme Yoga mat bag.
4. Jump Rope
Cardio is an essential part of any fitness routine, and a jump rope is an excellent choice for small spaces. The WOD Nation Speed Jump Rope is a popular selection among Reddit users for its lightweight design and adjustable length, catering to all user heights. Jumping rope is incredibly effective for burning calories and improving coordination.
Many users appreciate how easy it is to pack away after their workouts, and it can be used in almost any area of your home. Incorporating this into your fitness routine contributes to an effective cardio regimen that aligns perfectly with a compact best Reddit best NYC home gym.
- Elite Performance Gear: Experience the precision and speed of the WOD Nation Adjustable Speed Jump Rope, expertly crafted for both men and women. This indispensable piece of gym equipment enhances your workout efficiency, making it a must-have for elite athletes
- Effortless Adjustability: Customize your workout with ease using the adjustable length feature of this speed rope. It seamlessly supports transitions from singles to double unders, enhancing your home gym equipment with versatile functionality
- Durable Fitness Companion: Constructed from robust alloy steel, this jump rope is engineered to endure rigorous workouts. It stands as a reliable component of your home exercise equipment, supporting your fitness journey with unmatched durability
- Versatile Home Workouts: Elevate your home fitness routine with this adaptable jump rope, perfect for calisthenics and cardio exercises. It serves as essential gym equipment for home use, catering to both men's and women's workout needs
- Optimal Surface Protection: Preserve the integrity of your jump rope by using it exclusively on smooth surfaces. This ensures long-lasting performance and maintains its status as a reliable piece of gym accessories for both men and women
5. Indoor Bike Trainer
If you’re looking to cycle without heading to the streets of New York, an indoor bike trainer can help. The Conquer Indoor Bike Trainer is a top pick from Reddit, as it easily transforms any standard bicycle into a powerful training machine. This compact trainer enables users to maintain their cycling routine during inclement weather.
Reviews on Reddit indicate that users are impressed by its durability and ease of setup. The trainer is foldable, making it easy to store in smaller spaces, making it a perfect addition to your best Reddit best NYC home gym arsenal.
- 【Indoor Bike Trainers】: One of the problems with cycling, though, is that when the weather gets bad, conditions can keep you off the road or trail. Maybe it is raining or is too windy outside, or perhaps you need to avoid rush hour traffic or an unsafe dusk ride. This is when you just mount your bike on to a bike trainer and get the exercise that you want, but at home. There is no reason why you can not exercise with your bike when the outside weather is bad.
- 【Strong Structure & High Load-bearing Capacity】: The unfolded bicycle training stand forms a pyramid structure, which greatly improves the stability of the entire frame. Its strong material and stable structure enable it to withstand a weight of 330 pounds. In addition, any bicycle with a wheel diameter of 26 ''to 29'' including 700c can be fitted to our stand.
- 【6 Level Resistance Adjustable】: The trainer includes a drive-by-wire device so that you can change the resistance from your handle bars directly. You can adjust the magnetic resistor and switch the six resistance levels in seconds to meet your requirements about resistance and speed.
- 【Smooth & Low Noise Operation】: There is almost no sound on the wheels on the riding platform. It is recommended to replace smooth tires during cycling training to reduce vibration, reduce indoor resonance or add carpet under the stage. In some cases it will be loud with MTB tires. If you owned a MTB with rough tires, careful to buy. Because MTB tires will be loud with all bike trainers, no matter how expensive it is.
- 【Portable Folding Bike Exercise Stand】: In order to facilitate users to carry and store our bicycle training rack, we designed it into a folding style. It just takes a minute to set it up, clamp your rear axle with the quick clamp and adjust the contact between the wheel and the polished roller. No need to use other tools, you can directly complete the installation and disassembly process by putting up or unfolding the stand.
6. Compact Treadmill
Treadmills can take up a lot of space, but the Goplus 2 in 1 Folding Treadmill is an exception. It’s perfect for small apartments and is highly rated on Reddit for its versatility—acting as both a standard treadmill and a jogging machine. You can easily fold it and store it away after use, making it ideal for a NYC home gym setup.
Users have lauded its quiet operation and easy-to-use controls. The treadmill’s compact size does not compromise on performance, helping you get the cardio exercise you need despite limited space.
- INNOVATIVE 2-IN-1 FOLDING TREADMILL -- Compared to ordinary treadmills, our 2-in-1 Superfit treadmill has 2 modes to meet your different sports needs. When the riser is folded, it can be used as a jogging machine at a speed of 0.6MPH-2.5MPH, when the handrail is raised, the running speed is 0.6MPH-7.5MPH, and the speed unit could be switched between mile and km in APP.
- POWERFUL 2.25HP -- With a powerful and ultra-quiet 2.25HP motor, this Superfit treadmill allows you to walk or run without disturbing others, making it ideal for home and office use. With a sturdy and durable steel frame and multi-layer shield design, it's shock-absorbing and noise-reducing, making your running quieter, safer and more comfortable.
- NON-SLIP RUNNING BELT & MULTIFUNCTIONAL LED DISPLAY -- The 5-layer non-slip texture running belt features a spacious running area(39.3" x16"), providing an effective and safe cushion for your knees and muscles for a superior running experience. The LED display clearly shows time, speed, distance and calories, monitoring your progress in real time and keeping your movement data at a glance.
- WITH PHONE HOLDER, REMOTE CONTROL & APP CONTROL -- You can also use the phone holder to watch videos or chat with friends. The remote control (BATTERY NOT INCLUDED) is convenient to adjust the speed of movement and stop instantly. Smart APP control is perfect to record exercise data and running with other users.
- EASY TO MOVE AND STORE -- The compact, foldable design and built-in transport wheels make it easy to move and store this under desk treadmill to save space. And it's out of the box and doesn't need to be installed.
7. Kettlebell Set
Kettlebells are another versatile piece of equipment, offering a dynamic way to engage your entire body. The BalanceFrom GoFit Kettlebell Set is a recommended choice among Reddit users due to its accessibility and affordability. The set comes with multiple weights, catering to fitness enthusiasts at any level.
Users appreciate how kettlebells can be used for a variety of exercises, from strength training to high-intensity interval workouts. The compact nature of kettlebells makes them easy to store away when not in use, making them a perfect fit for the best Reddit best NYC home gym.
- Set of 3 - Set includes 3 kettlebells at 10, 15, and 20 pounds
- Ergonomic Handle - Wide and comfortable grips make these weights easy to hold and ideal for the maneuverings
- Rust Free - Made of durable vinyl and filled with cement, will not get rusty
- 10-Pound Kettlebell: 5" x 8.5"; 15-Pound Kettlebell: 6.5" x 9.5"; 20-Pound Kettlebell: 7" x 11"
8. Multi-Purpose Weight Bench
A multi-purpose weight bench is essential for strength training, and the FLYBIRD Adjustable Weight Bench is a popular selection on Reddit. It offers seven backrest positions and is foldable, which is a key feature for those with limited space. This bench is suitable for a variety of workouts, including bench presses, step-ups, and more.
Users frequently mention its sturdy build and comfort, making it an excellent addition for anyone looking to maximize their training at home. The ability to fold it away when not in use further contributes to its appeal as part of the best Reddit best NYC home gym setup.
- ASTM-Certified & 800lbs Heavy-Duty Support: Its elongated thickened steel frame, dual-triangle structure, and double-locking mechanism reliably support up to 800lbs; weighing 28.5 lbs, it is designed for fitness enthusiasts—whether beginners seeking long-term use or pros upgrading—the FB800 delivers a trustworthy solution in home gym
- 144 Adjustable Positions for Full-Body Training: With a range from -30° to 90° (flat/incline/decline/upright), this workout bench enables effective exercise for every major muscle group from chest and shoulders to core; The -10° decline offers a gentle intro to decline bench press lifting; Perfect 90° upright lock for shoulder & arm isolation
- Extra-Long Padding for Support & Focused Strength Training: A 30-inch elongated backrest offers stable support for your head and spine, while the 15.7-inch seat pad provides ample space during heavy bench presses; This design promotes proper chest engagement and prevents lower back arching—so you can push limits safely
- Spring-Lock Quick Adjustment & Adjustable Leveling Footpad: The self-rebound spring lock allows 1-second angle changes for both seat and backrest; The adjustable leveling footpad offer minor height adjustment, ensuring full stability even on uneven floors
- Space-Saving Foldable Design in 3 Steps: Fold the bench quickly into a compact size, reducing its footprint by 80%; Easily portable and stored, it fits in narrow spaces like beside the sofa or under beds, requiring only 9.06 inches in width—perfect for apartments and small home gyms
9. Stability Ball
Stability balls are excellent for core workouts and flexibility training. The Trideer Exercise Ball is a highly recommended product among Reddit users, offering great stability and support for a variety of workouts. It comes in several sizes to match your height and fitness goals, making it a versatile addition to your routine.
Users rave about how it can improve their balance and stability while being suitable for both beginner and advanced exercises. Plus, it’s easy to deflate and store away, adding to the efficiency of your best Reddit best NYC home gym setup.
- Designed with anti-slip stripes and a fine frosted texture for enhanced grip and stability. The increased surface friction ensures safe contact with both the floor and your body, keeping every movement controlled and confident.
- Made from premium, non-toxic PVC that meets California Prop 65 standards for safety. Climate Pledge Friendly certified, reflecting our commitment to sustainability and your well-being.
- Engineered to safely hold up to 330 lbs (150 kg) without losing shape. The burst-resistant structure with slow air release provides reliable performance and extra safety during all types of workouts.
- Ideal for yoga, Pilates, balance and flexibility training, and core workouts. Also doubles as an active sitting solution to improve posture and relieve back discomfort from long office hours.
- Comes with a quick-inflation pump (hand pump for 45/55/65 cm, foot pump for 75/85 cm), two air stoppers, and clear instructions. Available in five sizes to fit different body types and workout goals.
10. Foam Roller
Recovery is a crucial part of your fitness journey, and a foam roller is an essential tool to have at your disposal. The AmazonBasics High-Density Round Foam Roller is a well-reviewed option that is both affordable and effective. It’s lightweight, making it easy to transport and store, aligning well with the needs of NYC apartment dwellers.
Reddit users frequently cite its durability and the relief it provides for sore muscles, helping to integrate recovery seamlessly into their workout routines. This makes it an excellent choice for anyone setting up a balanced best Reddit best NYC home gym.
- High-density foam roller in Black
- Ideal for balance, strengthening, and flexibility exercises
- Firm, durable polypropylene maintains shape; molded edges for added comfort
- Lightweight and easy to carry to class and to reposition during workouts
- Wipes clean easily
Buying Guide for the Best NYC Home Gym
Designing the best Reddit best NYC home gym involves careful selection of products that fit your limited space while meeting your fitness goals. Here are some key factors to consider when building your perfect home gym:
1. Space Assessment
Before buying equipment, measure your available space and determine where you can fit gym essentials. Consider wall-mounted or foldable options to maximize your area effectively.
2. Versatility
Opt for equipment that can serve multiple purposes or through various exercises to ensure you’re getting the most value in a compact space. Adjustable dumbbells, resistance bands, and multi-purpose benches offer versatility.
3. Storage
Choose items that can be easily stored when not in use. Look for foldable gear or options that can be stowed away in closets or under beds.
4. Quality and Durability
Invest in high-quality products to ensure longevity and performance, especially during your workouts. Check reviews and look for trusted brands recommended within the Reddit fitness community.
5. Comfort
Comfort should be a priority. For example, when choosing mats or benches, look for options that provide enough padding and support for a variety of exercises.
6. Set Realistic Goals
Consider your fitness goals when selecting your equipment. If weightlifting is a primary focus, prioritize dumbbells and a weight bench. For cardio, focus on jump ropes or treadmills.
Conclusion
Creating the best NYC home gym in 2024 is not just about packing as much equipment as possible into a small corner of your apartment; it’s about selecting the right tools that suit your lifestyle and fitness goals. The products listed in this article reflect the highest recommendations from Reddit, combining functionality with space-saving features, ideal for urban living.
By following the buying guide and selecting from the top 10 products above, you’ll be well on your way to establishing an effective and enjoyable home workout environment that contributes to your fitness journey. The best Reddit best NYC home gym is within your reach—start building today!
Last update on 2026-03-08 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API | hishecozy.com is a participant in the Amazon Associate program and will earn from qualifying purchases.
